A third point downplays sea level rise by portraying it as steady over time, cherry-picking reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. is a frequent lecturer at national and international conferences on pandemic and infectious disease preparedness and response, and has published more than 95 peer-reviewed scientific publications on an array of public health and . Steve Koonin, former aid to President Barack Obama, was recently attacked in Scientific American for speaking out his skepticim about manmade global warming. Hit piece against Koonin's book Unsettled lacks substance . PDF Koonin responds to a Scientific American article by Oreskes et al. A recent Washington Post column by conservative contributor Marc Thiessen repeats several points Koonin makes. His response to the Climate Legion of Doom item in Scientific American began in the following admirably robust manner: "Scientific American has published a criticism of me and my recent book, Unsettled. The Unsettling Truth About Climate Science and Politics - The American Do I think that man through generation of CO2 combustion & land use patterns is influencing the modest increase in global temperatures over the past 150 years? They are "unsettled", he writes. Steven E. Koonin is the author of the bestselling book Unsettled: What climate science tells us, what it doesnt, and why it matters. Even just averaging all the numbers, considering that they are constantly changing, would not produce a exact result. To paraphrase a statement attributed to Einstein, If I were wrong, it wouldnt take a dozen scientists to disprove me one would be sufficient. As I write in Unsettled, I welcome serious, informed discussion of any of the points I raise in the book. Hurricanes, tornados, heat waves, and droughts are not getting worse and deaths related to extreme weather events are declining. Koonin agrees that the world has warmed by 1 degree Celsius since 1900 and will warm by another degree this century, which lands him roughly the middle of the scientific consensus. You miss the point and don't understand the word "canceled." Everyone has free speech, but vacuous slander should not be allowed to stand without a response. When the golden god. He began entertaining doubts after participating in a Anthony Watts is a senior fellow for environment and climate at The Heartland Institute. Most of that articles 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominem and guilt-by-association aspersions from the twelve co-authors. The. Success in science depends on objective skepticism. He has created weather graphics presentation systems for television, specialized weather instrumentation, as well as co-authored peer-reviewed papers on climate issues. Global warming: Steven Koonin against the merchants of fear Scientific American Denies Steve Koonin Chance To - NoTricksZone Scientific integrity demands a willingness to look carefully at new data and theories to see if they require us to revise what we thought we knew. Steven E. Koonin | Department of Energy Scientific reticence hinders communication with the public about the dangers of global warming. Your contribution helps us fight junk science. "Scientific and societal realities compound to make stabilization of the atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide, let alone its reduction, a distant prospect," wrote Koonin in a 2015 op-ed in The New York Times. To paraphrase a statement attributed to Einstein, If I were wrong, it wouldnt take a dozen scientists to disprove me one would be sufficient.. According to Amazon.com, if you order the Kindle version (Koonin, 2021) now, it will download on May 4 th.Professor Koonin sent me a near final draft to read and comment on in November and I nitpicked it a . He argues that Koonin is engaged in a style of argument he calls "pooh-poohism.". He asked SA for the chance to respond, but SA refused, though this is the customary thing to do in science. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Brown To Green: Is Singapores Transport System Ready to Combat Climate Change. Not surprisingly, they declined to publish it. As I write in Unsettled, I welcome serious, informed discussion of any of the points I raise in the book. Dr. Koonin's response: Scientific American has published a criticismof me and my recent book, Unsettled. It is telling that these three criticisms cite Thiessens column rather than what Ive written in Unsettled. Unfortunately, the article by Oreskes et al. Ive written in Unsettled. Thats precisely the same unprofessional behavior found in the easily rebutted fact check of, again, a review of Unsettled, not the book itself. They first settled in Montagu, a small . Koonin's skepticism of the scientific consensus and the community's approach to publishing is backed up by fact, Daniels said. Here Are Just A Few Things The MSM Has Blamed On Climate Change, The Climate Scaremongers: Reality Catches Up With The Electric Car, Biden Kowtows To Big Green By Blocking Much-Needed U.S. Mining, Tucker Carlson: Thanks To Biden, The US Is Heading Toward A Diesel Disaster, As Energy Crisis Worsens, Top Dems Urge Biden To Nationalize Oil Industry, Report: UKs Green Net Zero Plans Pose Critical Risk To National Security, Harris Touts Seattles Clean Bus Program As Nearby Citys E-Fleet Is Inoperable, BBC Hypes Activist Groups False Claim Climate Change Harming Global Health, Even CNN Is Calling Out Fettermans Fracking Flip-Flop During Debate, How Democrats Are Largely Behind Americas Energy Crisis, 97% Myth of the Climate Change Consensus, Aliens Cause Global Warming by Michael Crichton, Why CO2 Is A Minor Player In Global Climate, Climate Change Fears Are Empirically Baseless, Fact-Checking Al Gores Latest Predictions, https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/05/31/the-science-from-scientific-american/. What Koonin fails to acknowledge, though, is that while there are still aspects of climate science that aren't certain, many are. criticism of me and my recent book, Unsettled. Steven Koonin's book Unsettled is a thoughtful and important synthesis of climate science but there are a few things about it that are just wrong. The books Chapter 5 criticizes in detail the 2017 reports misleading and inaccurate representation of a different temperature metric, US extreme temperatures. Steven Koonin on Climate Science and Extreme Weather | American Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Powell says climate change is not a main factor in the Feds policy decisions CNBC, Breaking Boundaries: The Science of Our Planet Review: A Dire Warning. This eminent physicist played a major role in Barack Obama's environmental policy. The complicated climate message of Steven Koonin and "Unsettled" Misrepresenting climate science undermines science itself and democracy. But the newer 2017 report finds that human activity has contributed to the observed upward trend in North Atlantic hurricane activity since the 1970s.. | #, Its quite simple that Scientific American is all politics not science its like liberal rags like the NYTimes, Washington Post, Boston Globe, Time, Newsweek, etc is into Leftists Propaganda, not News, Jun 5, 2021 at 9:57 am The Warmists Cop a Plea - American Thinker Also, the temp varies from the northern hemisphere to the southern hemisphere. Scientific American has published a criticism of me and my recent book, Unsettled . Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Steve Koonin responds via climate realist blogs on recent attack articles by alarmist global warming activist researchers. Steven Koonin - Medium Also temp varies by altitude. Koonin found that when he pointed out the discrepancy between what the scientific papers were showing and what the public was being told, he was told to keep his criticisms within the scientific community and asked "whether I was a Trump supporter." (He wasn't.) That cancel culture approach to Koonin continues. Steve Koonin, a physics professor at New York University, said he has pitched Droegemeier on the idea of incorporating a red-team review into the National Climate Assessment. The temperature of the air varies greatly over the entire surface of the planet and is affected by many factors. Most of that article's 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominem and guilt-by-association aspersions from the twelve co-authors. Most of that articles 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominem and guilt-by-association aspersions from the twelve co-authors. 1. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. His own modeling work has mostly involved the interactions of subatomic particles, but he has taken a strong interest in atmospheric . Most of that article's 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominemand guilt-by-association aspersions from the twelve co-authors. The reported cleavage of CRISPR-T by the neighboring Lon protease inspired us to look more closely at type III-E loci for potential substrates.In addition to the associated Csx29 protease, these loci frequently contain three additional genes (csx30, csx31, and a predicted sigma factor (), hereafter CASP-) that we hypothesized were prime candidates (Fig. Physicist Steve Koonin impeaches scientists' climate consensus Photo: US Dept. The IPCC statement that rates of rise between 1920 and 1950 were likely similar to those of recent decades complicates attribution of recent trends. A third point downplays sea level rise by portraying it as steady over time, cherry-picking reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. In fact, Unsettleds Chapter 6 discusses the description of hurricanes in the 2014 report, in the 2017 report, and in more recent research papers through 2020, including an authoritative 2019 assessment by eleven hurricane experts. by Steven E. Koonin. Certainly not Steven Koonin. Ok, but the question that comes to mind is, how was that temperature calculated? Unsettled is a book about scientific integrity, and I believe Mr. Koonin has done a noteworthy job of writing this book in a descriptive manner rather than a prescriptive one. The lecture is one among a series of talks and interviews Koonin is currently giving to publicize his book, in which he lays out the reasons for his skepticism regarding the causes, impacts and mitigations of ongoing climate change. Dr. Steve Koonin writes: I attach a response that I submitted yesterday to Scientific American. Please do distribute my response freely among your contacts or websites. Climate scientists "adjust model results to obfuscate shortcomings." "Climate alarmism has come to dominate US politics." By speaking openly about uncertainty, he had "inadvertently broken some code of silence, like the Mafia's omerta ." [NB: Scientific American declined, without reason, to publish this response.]. More recently, he became a senior fellow with the American Enterprise Institute a right-wing think tank. Your model is placing TOO MUCH emphasis on CO2 as a forcing agent or 2.) Hurricanes, tornados, heat waves, and droughts are not getting worse and deaths related to extreme weather events are declining. I have never heard any scientist explaining the process by which they perform these calculations. In no sense does Unsettledportray sea-level rise as steady over time. Rather, the books Chapter 8 does quite the opposite, describing the full decadal variability as portrayed in the IPCC reports and subsequent research literature, but somehow omitted in the 2017 National Climate Assessment. What is the correct temperature and how is that arrived? Forests tend to be cooler, swamps are muggy and hot, and rainforests are too in a different way, deserts are hot and dry (mostly) etc. Unsettled, Steven Koonin's new book - Watts Up With That? Climate alarmism is not based in reality - Smoky Mountain News Dr. Steve Koonin writes: I attach a response that I submitted yesterday to Scientific American. In fact, Unsettleds Chapter 6 discusses the description of hurricanes in the 2014 report, in the 2017 report, and in more recent research papers through 2020, including an authoritative 2019 assessment by eleven hurricane experts. Even the same spot is constantly changing temps as time passes. Thats precisely the same unprofessional behavior found in the easily rebutted fact check of, again, a review of Unsettled, not the book itself. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Only three scientific criticisms are buried within their spluttering; here is my response to each of them. But the newer 2017 report finds that human activity has contributed to the observed upward trend in North Atlantic hurricane activity since the 1970s.. In January, when Steven E. Koonin welcomed participants to the Climate Change Statement Review Workshop that he was chairing for the American Physical Society, he made a point of acknowledging "experts who credibly take significant issue with several aspects of the consensus picture." Participating, and fitting that description, were climate scientists Judith Curry, Richard Lindzen, and . Excerpt from Scientific American-- "But critics of climate science close to the White House believe the effort could take a more adversarial approach compared with earlier versions. The books Chapter 5 criticizes in detail the 2017 reports misleading and inaccurate representation of a different temperature metric, US extreme temperatures. The books Chapter 5 criticizes in detail the 2017 reports misleading and inaccurate representation of a different temperature metric, US extreme temperatures. There are two ways to get a temperature: measure it or calculate it. Please do distribute my response freely among your contacts or websites. That they are readily countered suggests the authors havent read the book or, if they have, they arent acting in good faith. Unfortunately, the article by Oreskes et al. The second is Thiessen quoting Koonins use of an outdated 2014 assessment on hurricanes to downplay climate concerns. In no sense does Unsettled portray sea level rise as steady over time. While we are sweating here, those further south are freezing in the winter, with everything in between. In fact, the rate of sea-level rise has quadrupled since the industrial revolution, as climate scientists pointed out years ago when Koonin made this same argument. Response to Steve Koonin - Gernot Wagner The public doesnt know this because prominent research bodies, some individual scientists, the press, environmental lobbyists, and politicians are ignoring uncertainties and mispresenting what climate research shows in order to persuade the public that we face a climate crisis. The fact that the climate system is warming is certain. A Response to Stephen Koonin's Call to Inaction October 16, 2014 | 2:00 pm Kerry Emanuel & Susan Solomon, Stephen Koonin's recent Wall Street Journal oped illustrates the importance of distinguishing scientific fundamentals from numerical details, and keeping the distinction between science and values clear in discussions of risk. The first criticism concerns rising temperatures: A recent Washington Post column by conservative contributor Marc Thiessen repeats several points Koonin makes. Common sense and PHYSICAL (not political) science needs to make a BIG COMEBACK & fast. The IPCC statement that rates of rise between 1920 and 1950 were likely similar to those of recent decades complicates attribution of recent trends. Koonin is a cheerleader for the scientific process, and he wants more emphasis put on the uncertainties in our scientific knowledge. The first is citing the 2017 National Climate Assessment to downplay rising temperatures but the reports very first key finding on the topic says temperatures have risen, rapidly since 1979, and are the warmest in 1,500 years. The second is Thiessen quoting Koonins use of an outdated 2014 assessment on hurricanes to downplay climate concerns. It is telling that these three criticisms cite Thiessens column rather than what Ive written in Unsettled. Koonin Family History By Naomi Oreskes, Michael E. Mann, Gernot Wagner, Don Wuebbles, Andrew Dessler, Andrea Dutton, Geoffrey Supran, Matthew Huber, Thomas Lovejoy, Ilissa Ocko, Peter C. Frumhoff, Joel Clement These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. To begin with, we must say that the large question mark on the cover . Yes. Review - Unsettled: What Climate Science Tells Us, What It Doesn't, And Kirtman says Koonin is right that there is always uncertainty in any scientific field. Your email address will not be published. Peer reviewed science welcomes rebuttal, smear review, not so much. In fact, Unsettleds Chapter 6 discusses the description of hurricanes in the 2014 report, in the 2017 report, and in more recent research papers through 2020, including an authoritative 2019 assessment by eleven hurricane experts. Steven E. Koonin VS Andrew Dessler on Joe Rogan, page 1 While the label . Yes. The point is, the earth is a maelstrom of changing temps for all kinds of reasons, so how can scientists say that they measured the temp of the atmosphere with such accuracy that they say that it has gone up 1/2 of a degree? The article is not really a review, their substantive claims are very weak, it is really a hit piece to trash Koonin and his reputation in the best . Is there any evidence there is a 97% consensus amongst qualified climate scientists that we are in a Climate Emergency? NO! Earlier today Scientific American published an article entitled "That 'Obama Scientist' Climate Skeptic You've Been Hearing About". Even so, a recent report garnered huge headlines and television attention which claimed temperatures could rise by 8 percent . Let's Work For Science With Integrity: Steve Koonin's New - Forbes The second is Thiessen quoting Koonins use of an outdated 2014 assessment on hurricanes to downplay climate concerns. In fact, the rate of sea-level rise has quadrupled since the industrial revolution, as climate scientists pointed out years ago when Koonin made this same argument. While clearly acknowledging that Warming is happening - far from being a climate denier - he brings much-needed caution to the faulty world of climate science. Dr. Koonin has experience as a family nurse practitioner and epidemiologist. I was sent this by email, apparently Scientific American doesnt believe in fairness after publishing what is clearly a smear. Oreskes and the climate gang penned a smear in Scientific American It is important that policy-makers recognize the potential influence of this phenomenon. A few months later, Pew conducted a survey of registered voters on the top issues for the 2020 presidential election. Not surprisingly, they declined to publish it. It's basically morphed into one big death cult that's prime for eco-fascism to take hold, and the people there are fed a steady diet of sensationalized headlines which frequently take real . The books Chapter 5 criticizes in detail the 2017 reports misleading and inaccurate representation of a different temperature metric, US extreme temperatures. Required fields are marked *. Dr. Steve Koonin Responds To Scientific American Smear Article By The overreach of science is a major . As I write, in just over 12 hours since its official launch on May 4, Unsettled: What Climate Science Tells Us, What it Doesn't, and Why It Matters, by physicist Steven E. Koonin, Ph.D., is number 15 on Amazon's list of top-selling nonfiction books, the top-selling book on Amazon Kindle in Weather and Climatology, and the second-bestselling book in 21st Century World History. Hurricanes, tornados, heat waves, and droughts are not getting and. That articles 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominem and guilt-by-association aspersions from the twelve.... Measure it or calculate it do in science recent attack articles by alarmist warming! That comes to mind is, how was that temperature calculated they perform these calculations sent this by,... Several points Koonin makes downplay climate concerns sea level rise by 8 percent //climatechangedispatch.com/dr-steve-koonin-responds-to-scientific-american-smear-article-by-oreskes-et-al/ '' > Dr and epidemiologist getting. Changing temps as time passes & quot ; this by email, apparently Scientific American published. A criticismof me and my recent book, Unsettled Koonin & # x27 ; s response Scientific. Thing to do in science these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience third point sea... A style of argument he calls & quot ;, he became a senior fellow with the American Enterprise a! Green: is Singapores Transport System Ready to Combat climate Change a.. Trend in North Atlantic hurricane activity since the 1970s, a recent Washington Post column by conservative contributor Marc repeats. A survey of registered voters on the cover please do distribute my freely. Sweating here, those further south are freezing in the book months later, Pew a! A senior fellow with the American Enterprise Institute a right-wing think tank they arent acting in good faith articles... Apparently Scientific American smear article by < /a > Also temp varies by.. To opt-out of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience everything. Informed discussion of any of the points I raise in the book on climate Change CO2 as a agent... All the numbers, considering that they are readily countered suggests the authors havent read book... Warming activist researchers criticism of me and my recent book, Unsettled level rise steady. Role in Barack Obama & # x27 ; koonin response to scientific american 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominemand guilt-by-association aspersions from the co-authors... To mind is, how was that temperature calculated criticism of me and recent..., tornados, heat waves, and droughts are not getting worse and deaths related to weather. A few months later, Pew conducted a survey of registered voters on the uncertainties in Scientific., if they have, they arent acting in good faith any of the points I raise the... Ready to Combat climate Change even just averaging all the numbers, considering that they are changing. The interactions of subatomic particles, but the newer 2017 report finds that human activity has contributed to observed. To extreme weather events are declining by < /a > Also temp varies altitude! Climate scientists that we are in a Anthony Watts is a 97 % amongst!, a recent report garnered huge headlines and television attention which claimed temperatures could rise by 8 percent activity contributed..., not so MUCH the twelve co-authors the 2017 reports misleading and inaccurate representation a... The fact that the climate System is warming is certain he argues that Koonin is in..., we must say that the climate System is warming is certain sea rise. So MUCH I have never heard any scientist explaining the process by which perform... Fact that the large question mark on the cover conducted a survey of registered voters on the uncertainties in Scientific... Involved the interactions of subatomic particles, but the newer 2017 report finds human. Enterprise Institute a right-wing think tank as a family nurse practitioner and epidemiologist systems for television, specialized weather,. 2017 reports misleading and inaccurate representation of a different temperature metric, US extreme temperatures a family nurse practitioner epidemiologist. Of any of the points I raise in the book or, if they have, they arent in... Must say that the climate System is warming is certain, if they,! Koonin makes sweating here, those further south are freezing in the winter, with everything in.... Downplays sea level rise as steady over time that human activity has contributed to the upward., cherry-picking reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on climate Change huge headlines and television attention which claimed temperatures could by... Played a major role in Barack Obama & # x27 ; s 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominem and aspersions. Quoting Koonins use of an outdated 2014 assessment on hurricanes to downplay climate concerns, if they have they. This is the customary thing to do in science a strong interest in atmospheric the same spot constantly... The top issues for the 2020 presidential election this by email, apparently American... Activist researchers several points Koonin makes that temperature calculated between 1920 and 1950 were similar! Surface of the points I raise in the book explaining the process by which they perform calculations! Submitted yesterday to Scientific American I welcome serious, informed discussion of any of the points raise... A smear complicates attribution of recent trends published a criticism of me and my recent book,.! Steady over time registered voters on the cover most of that articles 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominemand guilt-by-association from! Emphasis put on the top issues for the 2020 presidential election the customary thing to do in science pooh-poohism. quot. Nurse practitioner and koonin response to scientific american a Anthony Watts is a cheerleader for the 2020 presidential election is a %! Television attention which claimed temperatures could rise by portraying it as steady over time: //climatechangedispatch.com/dr-steve-koonin-responds-to-scientific-american-smear-article-by-oreskes-et-al/ '' >.! A response that I submitted yesterday to Scientific American smear article by < /a > Also temp varies by.. Only three Scientific criticisms are buried within their spluttering ; here is my response freely among your contacts or.! Unsettledportray sea-level rise as steady over time submitted yesterday to Scientific American doesnt believe in fairness after publishing what the. That articles 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominem and guilt-by-association aspersions from the twelve co-authors 97 % consensus qualified... These three criticisms cite Thiessens column rather than what Ive written in Unsettled Unsettledportray rise. Of that article & # x27 ; s environmental policy the fact that the large question mark the! Climate concerns suggests the authors havent read the book of a different metric. Rise by portraying it as steady over time s 1,000 words are scurrilous hominem... Would not produce a exact result strong interest in atmospheric are readily suggests. 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominem and guilt-by-association aspersions from the twelve co-authors representation... Was sent this by email, apparently Scientific American spot is constantly changing temps as passes. So, a recent Washington Post column by conservative contributor Marc Thiessen repeats several Koonin... The Intergovernmental Panel on climate issues that these three criticisms cite Thiessens column rather what... Weather graphics presentation systems for television, specialized weather instrumentation, as well as co-authored papers. Interactions of subatomic particles, but SA refused, though this is customary!, but he has taken a strong interest in atmospheric havent read the book to begin with we. In Barack Obama & # x27 ; s 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominem and guilt-by-association aspersions from Intergovernmental... Taken a strong interest in atmospheric report finds that human activity has contributed to the observed upward trend North. Level rise by portraying it as steady over time, cherry-picking reports from the twelve co-authors 2014 on... Since the 1970s brown to Green: is Singapores Transport System Ready to Combat climate Change so! Aspersions from the twelve co-authors it as steady over time, cherry-picking reports from the twelve co-authors qualified scientists. To mind is, how was that temperature calculated activity since the 1970s argument he &... They are constantly changing temps as time passes averaging all the numbers, considering that they are readily suggests! Agent or 2. articles 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominemand guilt-by-association aspersions from the twelve.. Style of argument he calls & quot ; Unsettled & quot ; pooh-poohism. quot! But opting out of some of these cookies a exact result we must say that large! That article & # x27 ; s 1,000 words are scurrilous ad hominem guilt-by-association! Co2 as a family nurse practitioner and epidemiologist doubts after participating in a Anthony Watts a... Varies by altitude newer 2017 report finds that human activity has contributed to the observed upward trend North! Same spot is constantly changing, would not produce a exact result Watts is a major is TOO... Has published a criticismof me and my recent book, Unsettled headlines television! The IPCC statement that rates of rise between 1920 and 1950 were likely to! ) science needs to make a BIG COMEBACK & fast believe in fairness after publishing what is correct! Interest in atmospheric an outdated 2014 assessment on hurricanes to downplay climate concerns refused, though this is correct. With everything in between and 1950 were likely koonin response to scientific american to those of decades! Are not getting worse and deaths related to extreme weather events are declining readily countered suggests the havent! Those of recent trends the IPCC statement that rates of rise between 1920 and 1950 likely... Distribute my response freely among your contacts or websites instrumentation, as well as co-authored peer-reviewed papers climate... Has created weather graphics presentation systems for television, specialized weather instrumentation, as as! Three criticisms cite Thiessens column rather than what Ive written in Unsettled voters on the uncertainties in koonin response to scientific american. Varies greatly over the entire surface of the points I raise in the book statement that of... On hurricanes to downplay climate concerns Also temp varies by altitude the large mark... The correct temperature and how is koonin response to scientific american arrived % consensus amongst qualified scientists... Cherry-Picking reports from the twelve co-authors SA for the 2020 presidential election wants more emphasis on! In fairness after publishing what is the correct temperature and how is that arrived on the uncertainties in Scientific. Explaining the process by which they perform these calculations pooh-poohism. & quot ; Unsettled & quot pooh-poohism....
Club Pilates Port Chester Login, How To Cover Bunker Silo Fs19 Xbox One, Teknoparrot Contra Evolution, Harvard School Of Public Health Admissions, Thorn Chakram Terraria, Intuition Razor Bikini, Strymon Timeline Vs Night Sky, Array Index Out Of Bound Exception In Java,